Future Tense

This Year’s Indian Monsoon Could Be a Failure

A man in Punjab on July 6, 2014, when the temperature was more than 100 degrees Fahrenheit.  

Photo by STR/AFP/Getty Images

In large parts of India, the rains simply haven’t arrived this year.

At the end of June—the first month of what’s normally a four-month rainy season—India’s monsoon was running a whopping 43 percent below normal.

I’ve written previously that the Indian monsoon is the most important weather forecast in the world, and for good reason: Half the country’s 1.25 billion people are engaged in agriculture, and 70 percent of annual rains come between June and September. Irrigation is expanding, but most farmers still need the rains to have a successful harvest. There’s no larger group of people in the world more dependent on a single weather phenomenon.

Now, amid a persistent and sweltering heat wave, the country still waits for rain nearly halfway through what’s normally the monsoon’s second month. A staggering 32 of the last 39 days have been warmer than normal in Delhi, with not a drop of rain falling during that time.

The lackluster rains have motivated some people to call for immediate government action to stave off what could be a developing crisis. Newly elected Prime Minister Narendra Modi ran a campaign in part based on stemming inflation and spurring economic growth, which a monsoon failure may thwart. From Bloomberg:

“It now behooves all policy makers, at the center and the state, to start planning for the worst,” Saugata Bhattacharya, a Mumbai-based economist at Axis Bank Ltd., said in an interview to Bloomberg TV India yesterday. “The budget should now start to be leveraged for providing relief in the worst-hit districts, both by way of subsidies and movement of stocks.”

This year’s Indian monsoon is well behind schedule.

Courtesy of India Meteorology Department

According to the India Meteorological Department, as of July 9, the rains are now a month behind schedule in some parts of the country.

According to IMD statistics, all but two of India’s 36 administrative subdivisions have experienced below average rains so far this year, with one region—Gujarat—a whopping 92 percent below normal. Only 9 percent of India’s land area is currently classified as having “normal” rains.

In an update to its official seasonal forecast (PDF), the IMD now says the monsoon rains will be 93 percent of average this year, down from their initial 95 percent outlook. While those numbers may not look daunting at first glance, 93 percent of average would rank among the worst fifth of years since 1871. It also doesn’t reflect regional distribution of rainfall, which is often patchy in years with low monsoon rainfall. The IMD update cites “very high” chances of El Niño as a reason for the increased pessimism. (Earlier this year, the head of the IMD surreally accused Western weather forecasters of “spreading rumors” about a coming El Niño in an attempt to rig the Indian stock market.) Skymet, the leading private forecasting company in India, is much less hopeful, saying the odds of a failed monsoon, defined as less than 90 percent of average, have now risen to 60 percent.

What are the chances that the monsoon rains could stage a resurgence and finish close to normal? Given what’s at stake, I decided to run the numbers.

A few weeks ago, I cited recent research showing that the combination of El Niño (which is already taking hold in the Pacific) and a neutral Indian Ocean Dipole—an El Niño like pattern of periodic warming in the Indian Ocean—often leads to a failed monsoon. With a month’s worth of data in the books, it’s looking more and more like that could be happening this year.

Using IMD’s “All India” historical rainfall dataset (which dates back to 1871), last month’s rainfall total was the fifth lowest on record. Of the 10 driest months of June in India’s recorded history, nine of them went on to have below average rains for the full four-month monsoon season. Together, the five years with the driest June went on to average 93 percent of normal, in line with IMD’s current forecast:

Chart by Slate, data from India Meteorology Department

However, if you control for years with a building El Niño and a neutral Indian Ocean Dipole (both of which 2014 appears to have), the numbers look a lot worse:


Chart by Slate, data from India Meteorology Department

Given this (admittedly simple) analysis, there’s reason to believe this year’s monsoon now poses an 80 percent chance of failing.

There’s a shred of hope: Thunderstorms have finally entered the forecast in Delhi. The bad news: they’re still a week away.