The Slatest

New Soldiers’ Accounts of Brian Williams Incident Seem to Contradict Each Other

Williams receiving an honorary doctorate from George Washington University.

Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

On Wednesday, Brian Williams recanted a claim that his helicopter was hit by RPG fire in Iraq in 2003, but he has so far stuck by challenged assertions that his craft was part of the formation in which the helicopter that was hit was flying. Now Stars and Stripes and CNN have each published new accounts of the incident, quoting soldiers who were involved—and while the pilot quoted by CNN appears to partially exonerate Williams, the flight engineer who spoke to Stars and Stripes says Williams is still being “misleading.”

CNN spoke to pilot Rich Krell, who gave a version of events very similar to Williams’ past claims that NBC’s crew was flying in the same group of aircraft as the helicopter that was struck by an RPG.

Williams was in the back of Krell’s aircraft along with three other NBC staffers. Krell referred to his Chinook as the “second bird” in the formation. The “first bird,” right in front of the “second bird,” was struck by the RPG…

All three of the helicopters were hit by small arms fire, Krell said, supporting Williams’ past claims about that…The three Chinooks took evasive maneuvers. Krell’s helicopter dropped off its payload, then met up with the other two about 45 minutes later. That may explain why the other crew members told Stars and Stripes that Williams arrived in the area later.

Through Krell’s account would largely support Williams, the anchorman has always said that he was part of a group of four helicopters that landed “immediately” or “quickly” after taking fire, whereas Krell recalls a group of three helicopters, one of which carried Williams and took 45 minutes to land.

David Luke, a flight engineer who spoke to Stars and Stripes, more directly contradicts Williams. Luke says that on the day in question his and Williams’ Chinooks were part of a three-helicopter formation that merely passed the formation that ultimately took fire.

Luke said his formation of three Chinooks was carrying Williams and his NBC crew back toward Kuwait when they spotted a white Iraqi pickup truck, which stopped to watch the aircraft. They flew past quickly and continued on.

Soon after, Luke’s formation passed another company of Chinooks based out of Germany known as Big Windy heading in the opposite direction toward Baghdad, he said.

Luke’s Hercules Chinooks, carrying Williams and the NBC crew, soon heard over the radio that the Big Windy company they had passed came under fire from the pickup truck, he said.

Luke’s and Krell’s versions seem to mutually confound the situation, but point to potential pieces of clarifying information—which company the helicopter hit by the RPG was a part of and which company Williams was with. If Williams wasn’t even with the same helicopter company as the Chinook that was hit, it’s hard to believe that any of his versions of the incident are true. If he was, then his and Krell’s versions are more plausible. And presumably this clarifying information is available in documentation kept at the time by NBC and the military.