Picks

What’s the Best Coffee Maker?

Sometimes you just want to let a machine do the work.

assorted coffee makers
Photo: courtesy of the retailers

For all the debate over whether the best coffee comes from a Chemex or a French press or an AeroPress (even Nespresso), sometimes you just want to turn on a machine and let it do the work. We asked ten coffee drinkers — food-industry professionals and just plain coffee snobs — what’s the coffee machine that’ll get you a simple at-home brew without all the fuss?

The Bean-Grinding Coffee Maker

“On mornings when I don’t make a pour-over (weigh out the water, the beans, all that fun stuff), the Capresso drip machine yields the cleanest-tasting cup that brings out beans’ floral flavors, without burning the grinds or yielding an overly acidic cup. It’s also got a built-in, conical burr grinder, which saves you from having to buy a separate gadget, too.” — Kat Odell, author of Day Drinking

Capresso CoffeeTeam TS 10-Cup Digital Coffeemaker
Capresso

The Affordable Coffee Maker

“For home brewers, the Mr. Coffee 12-cup, programmable machine can produce great morning coffee that’s decent by most standards. Just make sure you use good water — NYC tap is more than acceptable, though filtered is even better. I’d say it’s also even more important to have a grinder that has a nice, even particle size distribution. I have a Baratza Encore on hand, but recently I’ve been relying heavily on the Handground brand grinder, which is a great ergonomic manual.” — Elliott Foos, barista at Café Integral

Mr. Coffee BVMC-SJX33GT-AM 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Mr. Coffee

The Pour-over-like Coffee Maker

“My boyfriend is a gadget nerd, and he bought the Bonavita 1900TS drip for us — it’s turned out to be pretty great. We had been using Chemex, but it’s hard to be patient in the morning! If you take the time you’d spend waiting for a pour-over and actually weigh the beans, then this baby is unbeatable. It tastes almost the same as the Chemex.” — Sara Conklin, owner, Glasserie

Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup Carafe Coffee Brewer
Bonavita

The Restaurant Coffee Maker

“I’d recommend nothing but the Bunn drip-coffee machine. It’s the machine you see most often used in restaurants and diners to make drip coffee for customers. They make a smaller version for about $130 that might not be the most attractive — but it’s entirely reliable.” — Amy Yi, executive sous-chef at Upland

BUNN BT Velocity Brew 10-Cup Thermal Carafe Home Coffee Brewer
Bunn

The Hot-at-the-Ready Coffee Maker

“We are a Cuisinart family. My mom still has the same food processor from the 1980s on the counter. When my co-host (and brother) Darin and I were looking for a coffee maker for our studio, that was the only choice for us. We loved this one because you set the time and forget it. We always work late, so this is a really nice end-of-day step, and then you get going without the bleariness of the morning. The thermal is a must as we drink throughout the day, and it’s great to just have it hot when we’re ready.” — Greg Bresnitz, co-host of Snacky Tunes

Cuisinart DGB-650BC Grind-and-Brew Thermal 10-Cup Automatic Coffeemaker
Cuisinart

The Smooth-Operating Coffee Maker

“My mom gave me a Gevalia 12-cup, programmable coffee maker a few years ago, and it’s gone with me through multiple Brooklyn apartments. It’s hard to find now, so if it ever breaks, she has a killer Cuisinart DCC-1200. I actually look forward to her coffee every time I’m home. It makes a mellow brew. If my Gevalia machine ever gives out on me, I’ll upgrade to that.” — Allie LaPorte, wine representative, Wilson Daniels

Cuisinart Central DCC-1200
Cuisinart

The Temperature-Consistent Coffee Maker

“I like the Technivorm Moccamaster because, from a scientific standpoint, it creates the proper water temperature (and temperature consistency) for good extraction of flavor from the beans. That’s the problem with most cheap automatics — they’re inconsistent about temperature. It also has a shower-head design for good water dispersion and saturation of the grounds. It consistently tastes almost (almost, I stress) as good as a manual drip.” — Andrew Chou, engineer, General Motors

Technivorm Moccamaster
Technivorm Moccamaster

The Large-Batch Coffee Maker

“To me, a great drip-coffee machine is a reliable one with a timer (which is an awesome feature for large families). The Cuisinart DCC-3200 might not be the first choice of snobby coffee experts, but to me it does the trick. It’s cheap and works just fine (it’s actually the one I use myself at home). I love that I can program the timer and wake up to the smell of fresh coffee. Also, friends and family think you’re the best host when they stay with you (even though you’re still sleeping).” — Guillaume Guevara, founder of Miscelanea NY

Cuisinart DCC-3200 14-Cup Glass Carafe
Cuisinart

The Simple-to-Use Coffee Maker

“I grind the beans in a Hario hand grinder gifted from my brother to me when he upgraded to a fancy electric one. Using the hand grinder is meditative. It feels like you’re ‘earning’ your morning coffee a little bit more. At home, I use a Muji porcelain pour-over, but when I’m at my family’s house in metro Detroit, I love using their Bonavita BV1800SS. Unfortunately, I don’t have one of my own, but seriously, you can’t fuck it up. Super-easy and delicious every single time.” — Kimberly Chou, co-director of Food Book Fair

Bonavita BV1800SS
Bonavita

This exact model is sold out on Amazon, but a newer eight-cup model of this Bonavita coffee maker is available from Walmart.

The Iced-Coffee Maker

“I actually didn’t start drinking coffee on a regular, daily basis until four or five years ago. I got hooked on the smoothness and low acidity of cold-brewed coffee, and for the longest time, my ritual each morning was to visit Gimme! near my house on Lorimer. Recently, though, I’ve started making cold brew myself at home with the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker. It’s not a true drip-coffee machine, but I’ve been very happy with this piece of equipment — it lets me tinker with different beans and concentrations, and produces enough cold brew to last me two weeks at a time. It also stacks compactly for storage, which is an absolute requirement for my tiny New York apartment.” — Dennis Ngo, caterer at Lonestar Empire

OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker
OXO

The Automatic Chemex

After asking the experts, I had to add my own coffee machine (one I’m currently saving up for). This is the dream because it has the reliability and old-school sex appeal of a Chemex, but the convenience of an automatic coffee maker. Plus, it’s just such a quirky mash-up that it’d definitely be a conversation piece sitting on the kitchen counter.

Chemex Ottomatic Coffee Maker
Chemex