Brow Beat

Dreamy-Smooth Hummus From a Kitchen Oops

Roasted carrots and za’atar oil over hummus in a dish on a table
Julia Gartland

What if every time we fumbled in the kitchen—a teaspoon for a tablespoon, baking powder for soda, a splash of vanilla for a whole tumbling bottle—could not only work, but also make something new and genius?

In a Murphy’s Law kind of way, it can’t. But every so often our bravery and curiosity and, yes, absent-mindedness can pay off, much like it did for cookbook author, podcast host, and journal editor Hetty McKinnon one night while she was off the clock.


“Sometimes I can be a pretty lazy cook, like when I’m cooking for my family,” Hetty told me as I interviewed her for the latest episode of the new Food52 podcast The Genius Recipe Tapes. One night, hustling to make dinner for her family, she said, “I basically opened a can of chickpeas and I thought I had drained them. … I hadn’t and I just tipped the whole thing into my Vitamix blender and then I thought: Oh no, what have I done?”


But rather than starting over, or fishing out and drying every pea, she decided to press on. She credits this bold move both to that self-professed laziness—and optimism that the extra chickpea liquid could simply replace the other liquids that she’d normally add, like water and olive oil.


“And, as I started whipping this thing, it started getting really big—much bigger than I normally get when I have hummus,” Hetty continued. “Normally you have to really work for that really smooth texture.”

She realized that the chickpea liquid had taken off its stuffy tie and jacket (“drain and rinse the chickpeas,” said every pre-2016 recipe) and put on its sequined aquafaba! costume, as the substance had been formally named that year—from the Latin bean (faba) and water (aqua)—before blooming into hordes of vegan meringues and foamy cocktails across the internet.

The inner workings of aquafaba are still somewhat murky and under investigation, but the starches and proteins released by soaking and cooking chickpeas do a bang-up job of whipping frothily like egg whites, capturing air that hummus recipes ordinarily wouldn’t.


A Vitamix, Ninja, or other high-powered blender seems to be the equipment best suited for inflating aquafaba, and some brands of chickpeas have less concentrated aquafaba than others. But I’ve found that if you start with a modest, not-entirely-brave quarter-cup of the liquid, then add more as needed, you can harness the wonders of aquafaba, no matter what beans and tools you’ve got.


Or you can be bold like Hetty, upend the can, and play with whatever happens next.

Whipped Hummus With Roasted Carrots and Za’atar Oil From Hetty McKinnon

Serves 4

Roasted Carrots and Za’atar Oil
• 1 bunch young carrots, trimmed and washed well
• 1 handful toasted pistachios, roughly chopped
• 1 handful parsley leaves, roughly chopped
• Sea salt and black pepper
• 1 tablespoon za’atar
• 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil
• Sea salt
• 1/8 teaspoon red chile flakes


Whipped Hummus
• 1 (439-gram) can chickpeas, with liquid (or 150 milliliters aquafaba with 260 grams cooked chickpeas)
• 2 garlic cloves, chopped
• 2 tablespoons freshly squeezed lemon juice (about 1 lemon)
• 1/3 cup (80 ml) tahini
• 1/8 to 1/2 cups (60 milliliters to 125 milliliters) water
• Sea salt and black pepper

See the full recipe on Food52.

More From Food52

How to Flambé (Yes, You Can!)
How to Make Indian Sambar at Home
How to Brine a Turkey for the. Juiciest. Bird. Ever.
Fudgy or Cakey? These Glorious Brownies Are Both.
10 Best Canned Tuna Brands for Sandwiches, Pastas, You Name It
How to Make Home Fries, the Superior Potato Preparation (We Said It!)