Yesterday, I bought a professional baseball player. It only took a minute. I surfed over to Real Sports Investments, clicked the “Buy Now” button, and purchased six shares of Randy Newsom. Along with my Slate colleagues John Swansburg and Dan Engber, I am now the proud owner of 0.0096 percent of a minor-league pitcher’s future major-league earnings. Mr. Newsom, I wish you a long and prosperous career—emphasis on prosperous. If Newsom makes $1,000,000 over the course of his major-league career, the Slate investment group will take a loss, earning a piddling $96 on an initial investment of $143.82. If he makes $10 million, we’ll get $960. And if he makes Barry Zito money? I won’t be retiring early, but I’ll be able to watch my baseball-playing property on some nice plasma TVs.
The 25-year-old Newsom, a midtier relief pitcher in the Cleveland Indians organization, is the first pro baseball player to hold a self-IPO. Real Sports Investments, the company Newsom hatched last year with two ex-ballplayer business partners, is fantasy baseball minus the fantasy. Newsom is selling off 4 percent of his potential MLB earnings at $20 per share. (A 15 percent “player valuation and share allocation fee” and a 2.9 percent “online processing fee” bump the price up to $23.97). A total of 2,500 shares will be offered, netting the pitcher $50,000 if they all get sold. As of today, investors can only buy shares; selling and trading will come soon, once RSI launches a snazzier Web site. And according to Newsom, this isn’t a “one-player thing”: In an interview with Baseball Prospectus, he says RSI is in talks with lots more minor leaguers.
The idea of buying shares in athletes isn’t new. Football Players Funds Management, a Portugal-based hedge fund, helps pro soccer teams buy the contracts of promising youngsters in exchange for a percentage of the players’ future transfer fees. Top poker pros are often staked for tournaments by investors, and a golfer might get his start on tour with backing from a consortium of investors. There’s already a popular fantasy site, ProTrade, where fans can buy and sell virtual shares in their favorite players. And last May, Michael Lewis wrote a convincing piece for Portfolio arguing that it won’t be long before Americans will be able to invest in their favorite athletes.
If the sports world turns into a trading floor, it probably won’t be on account of Randy Newsom. RSI, with its one-player stable, is more mission statement than business plan at this point. Newsom says the company has two goals: to give cash-poor minor leaguers a way to get capital and to strengthen the bond between fans and players. (You own six shares? Sure, I’ll sign that baseball.) “We feel like the business side will just come,” he says. “If we take care of the fans and take care of the players, the business is there.”
The business won’t be there without the approval of Major League Baseball. Newsom says he’s talked with MLB since going public, but RSI didn’t give a heads-up before its launch date. If MLB decides that selling a stake in your future earnings constitutes betting on baseball, then RSI is probably sunk. (Michael Teevan, a spokesperson for MLB, tells me via e-mail: “This seems to be a unique situation, and it’s one that we will look at closely.”)
Let’s assume that Real Sports Investments survives MLB scrutiny and recruits some more players. Will it work as a market? Jeff Ma, the co-founder of ProTrade and the leader of the Vegas-busting MIT blackjack team, says it’s a winning concept for minor-league ballplayers like Newsom. A ballplayer’s career carries substantial risk, Ma says, and it makes sense to shave off potential wealth in exchange for insurance against never getting a major-league payday. (If Newsom doesn’t make the majors, his investors get nothing.) Ma is skeptical, though, that players with higher earning potential will care to participate, and without these higher-tier prospects, the market won’t be as attractive to investors. “You’re not talking about Barry Bonds or [future stars like] Billy Butler or Tim Lincecum selling their future upside,” Ma says. “How many people will want to speculate on the Randy Newsoms of the world?”
Newsom acknowledges that he’s not a blue-chip stock—he refers to himself as an “anti-prospect.” He came into pro ball as an undrafted free agent from Tufts, and he throws his fastball around 83 miles per hour, relying on command and his sidearm delivery to deceive hitters. At 25, Newsom is old for a Double-A player who has yet to see the majors. Still, he’s no scrub, putting up a 2.51 ERA last season and making the Eastern League all-star team. I asked John Sickels, a renowned evaluator of minor-league talent, to give his assessment. “Newsom is a Grade C prospect, which means he has a chance to contribute in the majors but is not a top prospect or a likely future star,” he responded via e-mail. Sickels adds that he didn’t include Newsom in his 2008 Baseball Prospect Book “due to space limitations.” Number of players who were included: 1,074.
Newsom may be Real Sports Investments’ first product, but he doesn’t want to be the company poster boy. While he acknowledges that the game’s most promising young players—the high draft picks who rake in huge signing bonuses—likely won’t want to sell off future earnings, he insists that RSI won’t just peddle misfit anti-prospects. Newsom cites Johan Santana, who struggled in A-ball before becoming the best (and soon the richest) pitcher in the game, as a player who was overlooked early but cashed in late. But unless RSI is discernibly better than pro scouts at identifying hidden talent, the company will end up selling shares in lots of players who won’t stick in the majors and very few who strike it rich like Santana—most players who struggle in the lower minors never make it.
Newsom certainly won’t be Santana. In the very best case, he’ll be Scott Sullivan or Chad Bradford, a sidearming reliever with a steady major-league career. Newsom tells me he’d certainly be satisfied with the three-year, $10.5 million contract that Bradford signed with the Orioles last year. Most likely, Newsom will never see that kind of dough. RSI is selling 4 percent of the pitcher’s career income for $50,000, meaning his own company estimates Newsom’s career earnings at somewhere around $1,250,000. (Pritz says the exact details of RSI’s valuation model are confidential; Newsom says they ran “a lot of statistical regression models.”)
Is Newsom a good buy at $20 per share? I asked Henry Blodget to act as my financial adviser. Blodget laid out our assumptions on a Google spreadsheet that you can check out here. MLB’s minimum salary for the 2009 season (our guess for Newsom’s major-league debut) will be $400,000 before taxes. Shareholders will be paid from after-tax earnings but before agent fees and other expenses. Let’s figure that Newsom’s overall tax rate is around 50 percent. Let’s also give the Newsom shares a discount rate of 25 percent—an acknowledgment that investing in a minor-league relief pitcher is much riskier than, say, putting your money in Treasury bills.
Going off these assumptions, it appears that Newsom must make the MLB minimum (with regular small raises) for more than five years for total cash flow per share to approach $20. (Check out that spreadsheet here.) Considering our high discount rate, that career path would put the present value of Newsom shares at around $9. What if he makes about as much money as Chad Bradford? As seen in this revised spreadsheet, that would give the $20 shares a present value of $29. Since it’s fair to say that Newsom’s chance of becoming Chad Bradford is no greater than the chance he’ll fail to stick in the majors due to injury, a lack of opportunity, or a lack of skill, it’s hard to call the pitcher a good investment. Blodget notes that even if Newsom is an absolute star player, the value of the stock has a relatively low upper limit. Compared with a business, which has a theoretically infinite lifespan, a “human professional baseball career” only operates for a finite (and short) amount of time. “Given the likelihood that he’ll get hurt or flame out or just be average, I can’t say I’m jumping up and down to be the first to buy,” Blodget says.
Speculators probably won’t have any interest in a sports exchange that peddles bad investments. But perhaps Real Sports Investments isn’t really comparable to a stock exchange. In its current form, as a venue for needy minor leaguers to solicit contributions from fans, a closer analogue is Kiva, the popular Web site that connects microlenders to entrepreneurs in the developing world. Kiva has become a success by giving lenders a personal stake in the people they’re helping—say, a woman selling used clothing in Uganda—by documenting their stories and posting their photos. Real Sports Investments could work in the same way, with fans choosing players who appeal to them based on their particular needs (say, a newborn to support) and career goals (I’d send a few bucks to anyone who wants to lead the Mets to the promised land).
Newsom doesn’t think of himself as some kind of charity case, but he does see his $50,000 windfall as a way to level the playing field against guys who don’t have to worry about finances. He told me that he wants to invest the money he gets from investors back into his career by enrolling at Athletes’ Performance, a training facility in Arizona. It’s performance enhancement, without the drugs.
While a savvy investor would probably short his Newsom shares, I’m guessing there are plenty of sports fans who’d be willing to support him regardless. Take me, for example: After a few minutes talking to Newsom, I forgot that the point of this whole thing was to make money. Instead, I got caught up in Newsom’s dream to win a World Series. It would be a lot of fun to be even 0.0096 percent of making that happen.
Update, Feb. 2, 2008: I no longer own a professional baseball player. In an interview in Friday’s New York Times, Randy Newsom said he’ll return the $36,000 he earned from selling 1,800 shares—six to a Slate investment group—in his future major-league earnings. Newsom and his company, Real Sports Investments, neither registered their offering with the Securities and Exchange Commission nor sought approval from Major League Baseball before issuing the first-ever baseball player IPO. “We want to pause to hear everyone’s concerns,” Newsom told the Times. “This idea is not going away. This is assured by the amount of fan support, and the amount of players we talked to, that the support is there. The spirit of this idea will go on.”
Are these assumptions about Randy Newsom’s career all wrong? Send your breathtaking economic models to email@example.com. (E-mail may be quoted by name unless the writer stipulates otherwise.)