HOME / politics: Who's winning, who's losing, and why.

Reaction ShotThe raucous, ribald peanut gallery at Obama's address to Congress.

By Christopher BeamPosted Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2009, at 11:29 PM ET

Rep. Joe WilsonDuring any presidential address to a joint session of Congress, the president isn't the only one saying something. Members of Congress make a statement every time the president does—only with their feet instead of their mouths. (Although sometimes they use that too. Just ask Rep. Joe Wilson.)

RSS

President Obama's health care speech at the Capitol Wednesday night had more up-downs, cheers, jeers, and heckles than any State of the Union in recent memory. But behind every hoot, holler, and ovation was a complex, lighting-quick decision-making process. Let us break it down.

The pseudoscience of ovation-ology suggests that the president's speech was equal parts Democratic red meat and bipartisan overtures. By my count, the Democratic caucus alone stood and applauded 10 times during Obama's speech. Most applause occurred after determined or uplifting statements like "I will not let up until those Americans who seek jobs can find them" or partisan red meat like his quip that "too many initiatives over the last decade were not paid for." But Republicans applauded, too. The number of bipartisan standing ovations, with both sides of the House and Senate leaping to their feet, was nine. And once—after Obama's nod to medical malpractice reform—Republicans gave their own ovation.

Sometimes the appropriate response is obvious. When Obama said he wanted affordable insurance for everyone, GOP members rose to their feet, lest they risk being seen as churlish. When he mentioned medical malpractice, the Republican section responded with applause and hoots more likely to be heard in a beer hall than the halls of Congress. When he promised to "make sure that no government bureaucrat … gets between you and the care that you need," they had to applaud—the words could have been Sen. Mitch McConnell's.

Other times, Republicans were visibly conflicted on whether to clap or not. When Obama said that "our health care problem is our deficit problem," Democrats rose along with one Republican, Rep. Paul Ryan, who stood there with his lower lip thrust out as if to say, "Fair point." When the president made overt (some might say patronizing) attempts to reach across the aisle—"We should work together to address any legitimate concerns you may have"—the GOP side applauded, if grudgingly. The Republicans with the toughest jobs were the moderates: The senators from Maine, Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins, rose several times along with the Democrats, staring straight over the heads of their GOP colleagues.

Some individual members were animated throughout. When Obama said that slowing the growth of health care costs by one-tenth of 1 percent would reduce the deficit by $4 trillion, deficit hawk Paul Ryan rolled his eyes and grimaced, as if doing the calculation in his head. Republicans were also quick to laugh—a little too hard, perhaps—when Obama understated that "there remain some significant details to be ironed out."

But the guy who stole the show, of course, was Rep. Joe Wilson of South Carolina. When Obama said that health care reform will not cover illegal immigrants, Wilson shouted, "You lie!" Heads snapped, and the member next to him gestured for him to quiet down. Obama paused slightly and pointed, but seemed unfazed. (When the speech was over, Wilson vanished.)

Other members came equipped with props. When Obama said he would listen to the GOP "if you come to me with a serious set of proposals," a dozen members on the right waved aloft paper-clipped stacks of paper—bills, presumably. "Right here! Right here!" shouted one member. Others brought signs scrawled on the back of 8 1/2 x 11 sheets of paper. One GOP member alternated between flashing signs that read "What Plan?" and "What Bill?"

The speech was long—47 minutes—so members could be forgiven for zoning out. That seemed to be the case with John McCain, who took a long few seconds to perk up, smiling, after Obama praised one of his campaign ideas.

Democrats, for their part, had a much easier job: applaud as much as possible without making a fool of yourself. Most enthusiastic by far were Rep. Al Green of Texas, who shouted "That's right" when Obama said health care was a "moral issue" and waved his hand like an Atlanta Braves chop during lengthy ovations, and Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas, whose regular "mmm-hmm"s could be heard all the way from the balcony.

Do the ups and downs matter? Yes—for about five minutes. (Or, if you're Joe Wilson, until the next election day.) But for those five minutes, the outbursts, calculated or not, provide a brief glimpse into the opposition's psyche.

E-MAIL

RECOMMEND... Get Slate RSS Feeds

Christopher Beam is a Slate political reporter. Follow him on Twitter.

Photograph of Joe Wilson by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images.

COMMENTS

I understand there's a show associated with these speeches to joint sessions of Congress, just as there is with State of the Union addresses. You say something Dems like, Dems stand and clap. You say something Repubs like, Repubs stand and clap. You talk about how great America is, everyone stands and claps. (Honestly, it's like being at a concert. "We love you, Springfield!")

But to watch this speech, the old practice was particularly noticeable, and not in a way that was particularly flattering to Republicans. There were two particular points I can recall clearly, although I remember feeling this throughout.

The first was a line at the closing of the public option portion, Obama said something like "We want to give people a choice." Standing O from Democrats. Republicans... sit on their hands. Really? All of a sudden Republicans are anti-choice? What happened to the free market, guys? That one stood out.

The second, and more obnoxious, was in regard to the costs seniors pay for prescriptions. The line was like, "We hope to use those savings to bring down thousands of dollars in excessive costs seniors on Medicare are now paying each year for prescription medicines." Republicans... AGAIN sit on their hands? This was just offensive. Really, Republicans? You're FOR high prescription costs for seniors? This was a no-brainer. Obama could have said 'American workers are the best in the world' and it couldn't have been more obvious.

I believe the degeneration of the Republican party is complete. They're no longer even PRETENDING to care about the average citizens of this country. For the right, the goal has been nothing more than obstruction and obfuscation for some time, but this is pretty much the point where they just said eff it, I'm calling the president a liar and giving the middle finger to grandmas everywhere, just give me the power back already, it's all I really want or care about.

-- iwiwiwa
(To reply, click here)

It's an interesting point. Indeed, individual Republicans behaved so poorly that Rep. Wilson not only issued a mealy-mouthed apology, but is also reported to have phoned the White House with an apology.

I am interested in commentary that the degree of Republican rudeness was unprecedented in US history. Unlike the British Parliament, where members cry "hear, hear" to indicate their support and "shame" to indicate their disagreement, in our Congress members are expected to act with some decorum. These shouts, signs, and other forms of show and tell are not only out of the norm, they indicate disrespect both for the Presidency and for the country.

While I have read that in the period before the Civil War, members brought dogs onto the floor and picked physical fights with one another, I am totally unaware of a situation when a member of Congress comported himself so disrespectfully in formal context, when addressed by our President or any other President.

Curious that this comes from a party that insists that it stands for value and respect.

-- wellnw
(To reply, click here)

What did you think of this article?

Join The Fray: Our Reader Discussion Forum

POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES