The XX Factor: What women really think.

Did Socialized Medicine Kill Natasha Richardson?

Has anybody else been picking up on the effort to create a comparative health care storyline out of the Natasha Richardson tragedy? A friend mentioned a couple of days ago that she wondered if Richardson's death from "talk and die" syndrome would have been prevented had she fallen sick in the United States, and then today, this PR e-mail from a think tank that promotes health savings accounts arrived in my inbox:

NEWS REPORTS REVEAL NATASHA RICHARDSON’S DEATH MAY HAVE BEEN PREVENTED WITH U.S. HEALTHCARE

Lack of Equipment Under Government-Run System Delayed Lifesaving Measures

Washington, DC – News reports of the skiing accident, medical treatment and eventual death of actress Natasha Richardson last week shed new light on the limits of the Canadian health care. The timeline of the afternoon’s events indicate that the lack of medical equipment—a trauma helicopter and basic CT scanning equipment at the local hospital—delayed the treatment that may have saved her life.

Well, it's certainly possible. But I'd hope the Natasha Richardson Proof—the Canadian health care system didn't work perfectly for Richardson, ergo it sucks—doesn't become some major PR tactic during a health care debate, because it's a serious case of missing the forest for one tree.

A trauma helicopter might have helped Richardson, but on the flip side, in the United States such helicopters are generally way overused, in part because they're profit makers and because the burden of their costs is distributed in such a way that it isn't appropriately felt: This past September, a Medevac chopper crashed in Maryland, killing three personnel (including one ambulance volunteer, a gig I've done) and one of the two wounded girls it was transporting from the scene of a car crash. Both girls originally had non-life-threatening injuries. "We've just gotten into a situation here in the United States where we think that the helicopters are a panacea," an emergency medicine researcher told the press after the accident. The September crash, sort of the reverse image of the Richardson incident, could be considered an event in which the overabundance of medical equipment killed.